Jill St. Claire's HomelandSecurityUS.NET

The scientists fatwas in Ibn Hajar's affair and the nuclear one

8-25-2005

 

In the Name of Allah, the Benificent, the Merciful the twelfth question from the fatwa no. 4264 : the question : for Imam Al-Nawawi some of the brothers say : it is Asha'ri in the names and the attributes then does this be correct, and what is the evidence, and does the speaking with respect to the scientists in this image be correct and from them who said : there is for it a book it ( the knower orchard ) names and he is a Sufi in it, then does this speech be correct ؟

The praise of Allah and the prayer and the greeting is on its messenger and its family and its friends ..And till now :

ج : for him mistakes in the attributes he cleaned in him the behaviour of the interpreters and erred in that, then he is not imitated him in that but the duty the sticking to the opinion of the Sunnis and he is the registration of the names and the attributes mentioned in the Mighty Book and the cleansing right Sunna, and the belief in that on the face proper by Allah became great and rose from not a distortion and no hindrance and from not an adaptation and no exemplification compliance with his saying glory be to : ( he is not as his like a thing and he is the seer hearer ) and what came in his meaning from the verses . And by the guidance Allah and Allah invoked peace upon our prophet Mohamed and its family and its friends and greeted organ Permanent Committee for Academic Research and Fatwa : Abdullah is sitting son . An organ : Abdullah is kids son . The committee vice chairman : Abdul Razzak Afifi .

The president : Abdul Aziz Bin Abdullah Bin Baz .

The reference : the Islamic Research magazine the number 39 p. 111-112 .

-----

And in another place in the source himself she is asked the committee a long question around the Ahl al-Sunnah wal Jama`ah dogma in the names and the attributes and around the attitude from the scientists who interpreted the attributes of Allah the Exalted the Majestic and answered expanded answer that came in it :

A fourth : our attitude from Abu Bakr Al Baqllani and Al Baihaqi and Abi Al-Farag Ibn Al Jawzi and the nuclear Zakariya father and Ibn Hajar and their proverbs who interpreted some of the God's attributes rose or authorized in the origin of its meaning ،

They are in our view from the Muslims scientists seniors

The ones who benefitted the nation Allah by their science, then all-embracing mercy Allah had mercy on them and rewarded them about us the reward wealth

And they are from the Sunnis while agreed on him with the Companions May Allah be pleased with them and the ancestor imams in the three centuries that the prophet testified to peace be upon him with the good،

And they erred while they interpreted from the attributes texts

And they disagreed on it with the nation ancestor and the year imams Allah had mercy on them ،

Whether they interpreted the personal attributes the actions prescriptions or some that

And by the guidance Allah and Allah invoked peace upon our prophet Mohamed and its family and its friends and greeted

Permanent Committee for Academic Research and Fatwa

An organ : Abdullah is sitting son . An organ : Abdullah is kids son . The committee vice chairman : Abdul Razzak Afifi .

The president : Abdul Aziz Bin Abdullah Bin Baz .

The Islamic Research magazine is p. 123-124 and the question stated a complete with the answer from p. of 118 to 124

The source ( clouds network )

http://www.sahab.net/sahab/showthread.php?s=&threadid=242649

----

The weak slave said the writer of these lines : by these fatwas I say and he believed .


Abu Qlaba said : what a people created an innovation except they regarded as lawful in it the sword, to my correspondent Http : / Korah.arabform.com
Earliest MessagesPrevious MessagesAll MessagesOutline ( 20 the previous topics )
  orabi 23-8-2005 19:25 21.  

 

The brother said that a ball in the response is a number ( 19 ) :

I say Lourabi, what is the difference between Ibn Hajar and the nuclear one and Ibn Qotb؟

All fell in the innovation with its belief !

And Ibn Hajar and the nuclear one is Ash'ari, and the Ash'ari are not from the Sunnis .

And Sayed Qotb is external the rejecters of each affliction in him .

As for Wahid Aldin betrayed then I say for him .............And so on

I say :

The first line : I understand from it that you did not differentiate between an imam as Ibn Hajar or the nuclear one and a man of letters as Sayed Qotb in the dealing at all, but she included all by a single referee, and it did not give the ancestors any advantage or a consideration, this what he understood, or the rule differed !!!

And I want from you previously considering from the contemporary scientists, then I hope that he helps me by the one(s) who equalized between them .

The third line O brother is a ball it shows that you do not consider Ibn Hajar and the nuclear one from the Sunnis but they are Ash'ari !!

And I think this does not agree what wanted that she writes it in the topic origin !!

 

 



The critics father fascinated them by its talk [ I am the Salafiya city and the insult its door ], then they preceded the chapter and have each of them is its religion before and from an end ... He what a bad the odor they !!
  orabi 24-8-2005 03:13 22.  

We expect the answer from the brother a ball .


The critics father fascinated them by its talk [ I am the Salafiya city and the insult its door ], then they preceded the chapter and have each of them is its religion before and from an end ... He what a bad the odor they !!
  The time talk 24-8-2005 08:34 23.  

orabi

If she notices that it go out Ibn Hajar and the nuclear one is from the circle of Sunna and group

And he made them of the group 73 that in the fire

He did not differentiate between the world if mistakes unintentionally

And a love accompanied


Dubaibeams @ Yahoo.com is this a postal of who wanted is that it shows by its opinion in the Arab arena then to it favours a thanked
  orabi 25-8-2005 17:54 24.  

The brother is the time talk : we wait from a ball that he answers what confused him .


The critics father fascinated them by its talk [ I am the Salafiya city and the insult its door ], then they preceded the chapter and have each of them is its religion before and from an end ... He what a bad the odor they !!
  The time talk 25-8-2005 19:07 25.  

 

Allah repairs you O Orabi

The ball embarrasses by the question and wants from it the answer !!

And he comes Shrgawi and explodes it an explosion with its next question

Who { book realized the belief } to Ibn Taimiyya and the belief { book } to Ibn Abi Shiba and the belief { book } to Ibn Salam

The ball he does not know the books of its sheikh Abdul Latif Bashmil !!!


Dubaibeams @ Yahoo.com is this a postal of who wanted is that it shows by its opinion in the Arab arena then to it favours a thanked
  The virtuous 25-8-2005 20:48 26.  

An Orabi brother - Allah guided you - it says an addressing the writer is a ball

: ( and I want from you previously considering from the contemporary scientists, then I hope that he helps me by the one(s) who equalized between them .)

I say :

The writing generous brother is an attack he does not equalize between Sayed Qotb the ignorant man of letters by the sharia and between the imams Ibn Hajar and the nuclear ones and Al Shawkani ....

But its saying promises a frank Sayed Qotb is first with the excuse from Ibn Hajar and the nuclear one because the first is an ignorant and as for rest then they scientists knew the texts and the sharia !

This is what he decides a ball and does not deny it at all

But brother this consolidation that saw it to the writer a ball contradicts it and annuls it from his exponent with his saying the sheikh Ibn Athimin apologizes to him because he is a scholar when he said an expression in it the postponement and the exit ( on the limit of his claim ) in his approval on the Albanian : ( you established the Islam country in he molded you that makes for you on your land )

And so Ibn Baz apologizes to him because he is a world and a scholar when he said about Al Qaradawi : the His Eminence Sheikh

With the disagreement of the Albanian sheikh then he does not apologize to him because he is not by a scholar

And I hope that she have stood maybe this strange contradiction is !

ـــــــــــــ

I said the generous brother : (

The third line O brother is a ball it shows that you do not consider Ibn Hajar and the nuclear one from the Sunnis but they are Ash'ari !!

And I think this does not agree what wanted that she writes it in the topic origin !!)

I say :

Brother is also in this a contradictory a severer of the contradiction as is the habit of the loves people then he reconsidered my responses to him here in this topic

Allah guided you and helped you Lord on each good .

 

 


 HOME 

 ©2003-2008 All Rights Reserved Jill St. Clare's HomelandSecurityUS.NET